In Remembrance.
 

In Remembrance

Ron Carne
Lila Gosch
Jessica Holland
Emmy Mumford King
Jim Saxe
Larry Thatcher
Annemarie Troeger
 

Charles Edmund Lazar Horman

1942–1973
Charles and Joyce Horman, 1971

Charles Horman and Frank Teruggi, Jr. were Americans in Chile during the coup d’état led by General Augusto Pinochet to overthrow the democratically elected president, Salvadore Allende, and impose military rule. They were among the thousands kidnapped, interrogated, tortured, and executed by the military regime. Their ordeal was the basis for the 1982 film, Missing, by Costa-Gavras. Charles’ wife, Joyce Horman, has led a many-year campaign to bring out the truth behind her husband’s murder. The U.S. military and the CIA backed the military coup and were complicit in the murder of the American journalists.

As stated by Joyce Horman on September 11, 2013:

My journalist husband was murdered because he knew too much about Pinochet's US backers. Accountability is 40 years overdue.

Forty years ago, during Chile's bloody coup of 11 September 1973, my husband, Charles Horman, stepped into a car driven by Captain Ray Davis, the head of the US military group in Chile, for a ride from the coastal resort town of Viña del Mar to the capital of Santiago. That one journey forever changed our family, and placed me on a quest for justice that persists to this day.

Charlie was a journalist, and we both were enthusiastic supporters of the democratically-elected socialist president, Salvador Allende. When General Augusto Pinochet launched his coup against Allende from the same coastal town Charles was visiting, my husband was surprised to see not only many Chilean tanks and helicopters moving out, but US warships cruising just off the coast, and US military personnel on the ground. He overheard some of those personnel enthusiastically and eagerly taking credit for the success of the coup, implying US military involvement. Charlie dutifully took his notes.

Before he, and our visiting friend from New York, Terry, began their journey with Davis, Charles knew he had come upon dangerous information. The drive past heavy military roadblocks into the heart of Santiago where Pinochet's forces were on a search-and-destroy mission for Allende supporters, provided the perfect opportunity for Davis to evaluate Charles and his loyalties. This reality did not escape my husband, and he began to fear Captain Davis.

Charles returned to our home in Santiago, and as he recounted his journey and discoveries to me, we resolved to leave the country. On 17 September, we separately embarked on our errands for the day, and kissed each other goodbye. I did not realize at the time that I would never see my husband alive again.

Later that day, Charles was abducted from our home by more than a dozen Chilean soldiers. He was brought to the national stadium, where some of the most brutal of the regime's crimes were carried out against presumed Allende sympathizers. When I returned to find our home in disarray, and Charles missing, I feared the worst.

In the days and weeks that followed, Charles' father, Ed Horman, and I sought the help of American officials. Rather than aiding our search, however, they inquired about our social circles, and asked if we had been annoying the Chileans. Gradually, it dawned on us that our worst fears were well-founded. If it had been made public, the information that Charles had acquired would have risked derailing the recognition of Chile's junta by the US government. In that context, Charles was transformed from an American citizen who was entitled to protection, to a vulnerable and disposable threat to powerful forces.

A month would pass before it was revealed, through help from the Ford Foundation, that Charles had been executed—his bullet-ridden body buried in a wall in the national stadium. Yet, it was not until after Pinochet's 1998 arrest in London, that an era of renewed pressure for accountability regarding the regime's crimes would drive the Clinton administration to declassify many previously-redacted texts about that terrible time. According to one document:

US intelligence may have played an unfortunate part in Horman's death. At best, it was limited to providing or confirming information that helped motivate his murder by the GOC [government of Chile]. At worst, US intelligence was aware the GOC saw Horman in a rather serious light and US officials did nothing to discourage the logical outcome of GOC paranoia.

Throughout these 40 years, our family has never relented in our search for truth and accountability around Charles' death. We filed a case against Henry Kissinger in 1976. In 1981, it was dismissed without prejudice—free to re-open when more evidence became available. I personally testified in the House of Commons during Pinochet's arrest in London. Our December 2000 case in Chile against Pinochet forces is still under investigation.

A year ago, Chile's supreme court approved investigative Judge Zepeda's request for extradition of Ray Davis to Chile concerning the deaths of Charles Horman and Frank Teruggi, another American journalist who was killed during the coup. The US has not yet been served with the extradition request; if and when that happens, it would set an important precedent for a US military officer to be charged by another country for the death of American citizens. [Editor’s note: The Associated Press in Santiago subsequently reported that Ray Davis had secretly been living in Chile, where he died in a Santiago nursing home in 2013.]

In the 40 intervening years, some wrongs have been revealed and some cases have been tried in Chile, which is, again, a democracy. Pinochet's arrest certainly served as a lightning rod to broaden the global mechanisms to hold human rights violators accountable. But there is still a long way to go: the United States military continues to lie to the public, and take every opportunity available to cover up their abuses of power. We all have an interest in uncovering the truth about whether Captain Ray Davis played a role in the death of my husband.

In that sense, Charles' story is just as relevant today as it was 40 years ago, and makes the cases against those responsible just as pressing. Charles' mother, Elizabeth, often used the refrain, we will leave no stone unturned. That, too, is my mission, and should be the goal of all those dedicated to a just world in which no individual is too big, or too powerful, to answer for their crimes.

References

Justice for Charles Horman—and the Truth About the US and Chile’s Coup, by Joyce Horman, The Guardian (US edition), 11 September 2013. Link

Chilean Court Rules US Played Key Role in Pinochet Murder of Americans, by Barry Grey, World Socialist Web Site (wsws.org), July 3, 2014. Link Also reported on The Greanville Post Web site. Link

American journalist Charles Horman was Murdered with the Help of the US Government, a Chilean court finds, PRI’s The World (www.pri.org), July 1, 2014. Also, an audio recording of Joyce Hackel interviewing Joyce Horman. Link

Charles Horman Truth Foundation (hormantruth.org). Link

What Were the Standards for Executing Charles Horman? by Jacob G. Hornberger, Hornberger’s Blog, The Future of Freedom Foundation (www.fff.org), February 8, 2013. Link

U.S. Victime of Chile’s Coup: The Uncensored File, by Diana Jean Schemo, The New York Times, Febriary 13, 2000. Link

State Department Release on Chile Shows Suspicions of CIA Involvement in Charles Horman Missing Case, The National Security Archive at The George Washington University (https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu), October 8, 1999. Link

On October 8, 1999, the U.S. Government released 1100 documents on Chile. Among them is a declassified State Department report on the case of Charles Horman, an American citizen who was killed by the Chilean military in the days following the coup.

This document was released once before in 1980, pursuant to a lawsuit filed by the Horman family. At that time, significant portions were blacked out.

The version released today reveals what was censored: the State Department's conclusions that the CIA may have had "an unfortunate part" in Horman's death.

New Information on the Murders of U.S. Citizens Charles Horman and Frank Teruggi by the Chilean Military,“ National Security Archive Electronic Briefing Book No. 33, published June 30, 2000. Link

Joyce Horman Audio Interview. Joyce Horman, the wife of journalist Charles Horman, who was killed in Chile during the military coup of 1973, interviewed by Lisa Mullins (theworld.org) in 2011, published August 16, 2013, YouTube. Link

Chilean court links US Intelligence to 1973 Killings of Two Americans, Associated Press in Santiago, July 1, 2014, reported in The Guardian. Link

Charles Horman, Wikipedia. Link

Missing (1982), a film directed by Costa-Gavras and starring Jack Lemmon and Sissy Spacek.